Senior New Zealand Police Minister Continues to Endorse, Encourage, Enable Prison Rape

Photo via Stuff.co.nz. Cached as a bandwidth-conserving courtesy
Photo of NZ Police Minister Judith Collins via stuff.co.nz

New Zealand blogger Maia says the recent earthquake seems to be giving the local justice department head an opportunity to further indulge in rape culture and, by extension, homophobia.

From the [New Zealand] Herald: Police Minister Judith Collins said the actions of looters was akin to “people who rob the dead”. She expected to see the judiciary throw the book at looters.

“I hope they go to jail for a long time – with a cellmate.”

Judith Collins introduced widespread double-bunking; she championed it in the media. When people who had actually done research suggested that it would lead to more prison rape and violence, she shrugged those statements off.

And now she’s telling us that, for her, abuse and violence between inmates is a feature of double-bunking, not a bug. She is not explicit, but we live in a culture where threats of rape in prison are common enough that she doesn’t need to finish the thought by telling us that the cellmate is large and called Bubba. By signalling that she thinks looters should be subject to rape and violence from their cell mates, she has acknowledged that her policy of introducing cellmates is responsible for increased rape and violence.

Source: Alas, a blog

This is pretty cool.  I'm glad she brought it up.

Few things identify rape culture quite like the assumption that it will be the new, the young, the white, the middle-class, the petty-criminals, or the white-collar criminals who will become the victims of prison rape when inmates are “doubled up” unsupervised in cells.

Similarly, few things identify rape culture quite like the assumption that if assertions like Collins’s are true then the prison system rewards, encourages, coddles, or even tacitly recruits those who really are prison rapists by providing them with more victims.

And finally, few things identify rape culture quite like the general failure of progressives to push back on the previous two assumptions.

While rates of rape and sexual assault seem to be in decline in the general population, prison rape remains a huge reservoir not only of future perpetrators but of current ones! And of current victims. Thanks so much for bringing this up and for making the connection so clearly.

Couple other little assumptions in there

  • That only prisoners sexually assault or rape prisoners
  • That only male prisoners sexually assault or rape fellow prisoners
  • That (dreadful as it sounds) rape and sexual assault is the worst thing that can happen to one in prison.
  • That sex between prisoners is inevitably non-consensual, or that loneliness and isolation can never be so great that otherwise straight prisoners never seek or form intimate or sexual bonds with each other.

But the main thing is that New Zealand's senior police official thinks that "tough on crime" means incorporating prison rape into corrections policy rather than opposing or working to minimize it.  She's not alone.


Tags:

the first and second

Submitted by Pearl (not verified) on Mon, 2011-02-28 15:59.

the first and second assumptions seem off base but the 3rd is pretty high up there. confinement and being stripped of civil liberties while looking at option of abuse or solitary confinement are pretty dire. 4th presumption may happen but would people cry foul in those cases.

her idea that crime should be punished and we should have no compassion for figuring out with the person how to address issues for better results is pretty common unfortunately. each conservative upswing seems to go back to draconian models.

http://home.cc.umanitoba.ca/~

Submitted by Soren (not verified) on Mon, 2011-02-28 16:02.

http://home.cc.umanitoba.ca/~altemey/ You should read this guy's stuff, he's got quite a lot to say about that tendency.

Also, don't discount the

Submitted by Soren (not verified) on Mon, 2011-02-28 16:01.

Also, don't discount the possibility that they may be throwing these new inmates in with people who will become their first of many victims. Plenty of serial rapists probably develop a taste for violent nonconsensual sex in prison that they take with them into the wider world when they're released.

Since I'm a New Zealand

Submitted by Lynet (not verified) on Tue, 2011-03-01 13:51.

Since I'm a New Zealand citizen (my family is in Christchurch, no less), I wrote to Judith Collins about that comment.  My email read:

Dear Ms Collins,

I recently read the following article in the New Zealand Herald about looters after the Christchurch earthquake:

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10709042

In this article, you are quoted as saying "I hope [looters] go to jail for a long time - with a cellmate."

I am a Christchurch native, currently living overseas, but I still take a strong interest in what is happening at home, particularly with the recent disaster.  Obviously I am disgusted at the actions of looters, heartbroken by what the earthquake has done to my city, and proud of those who have stepped up to help out in the aftermath.

I am also outraged by the reference to prison rape in your comment above.  You are the Police Minister.  Your position ought to be one of support for justice, and rape is not justice, not ever.  You make me ashamed of my country.  I hoped we were better than that.

I hope you will reconsider your position with regard to the cruel and unusual punishment of rape in prison.

Sincerely,

I have since received the following response (written by a staffer, but signed by the minister):

Dear Ms Mason

I have never made any such suggestion around sexual abuse and I am frankly appalled that anyone would seek to accuse me of it.

Yours faithfully

Judith Collins

I have written back asking, politely, whether the Herald quoted her wrongly, or whether she merely meant that it would be particularly fitting if looters did not have a lot of personal space while in prison.  I'll let you know if I get a second response that is especially enlightening.  At any rate, assuming she did say it (which, let's face it, is not unlikely), hopefully she'll consider what such statements actually mean and refrain from making them in future.

User login