Upon Seeing Joe Wright's "Anna Karenina"


Anna Karenina - Dance with me by teasertrailer. I wish I could have found a better clip. Forgive the opening commercial --fl.

Loved the "waltz" scene with all my heart.  It was evidently absolutely fabricated by the choreographer, Sidi Larbi Cherkaoui -- neither Russians nor anyone else in the 1870s (or any other time) engaged in such fluidly graceful ballet of the hands -- but it was amazing to watch.

Actually, the choreography was the best part of the show.  No, it wasn't terriffically faithful to Tolstoy's text but then a ballet based on the novel wouldn't have either, and I doubt many would have objected to that.

Actually I think the worst part of the movie was... it was still faithful toTolystoy's text!  Geez what a creep!  By all accounts it was horrible enough being a part of his real life, particularly if you were female.  To be a character in his novel would leave one completely at his mercy!

In one of her best known works, Intercourse , Andrea Dworkin dwells on Tolstoy at length.  The guy was a complete asshole to his wife -- nearly killing her with repeated pregnancies while also repeatedly excoriating her for "forcing" him to backslide into sexuality despite his public yearning for pious celibacy and male chastity.  (Her diaries tell a story different enough that even if you average the competing claims he's... still an asshole.)

Early in the story Tolstoy has the title character, Anna, travel to Moscow to persuade her brother's wife to forgive him for his affair with their nanny.

The brother, Stiva, is presented as an affable, emotionally content, and ultimately simple man.  His take on his affair? (emphasis mine)

And then he suddenly remembered how and why he had been sleeping, not in his wife's chamber, but in the library; the smile vanished from his face and he frowned.

"Akh! Akh! Akh! Akh!" he groaned, as he recollected everything that had occurred. And before his mind arose once more all the details of the quarrel with his wife, all the hopelessness of his situation, and most lamentable of all, his own fault.

"No! She will not and she cannot forgive me. And what is the worst of it, 't was my own fault — my own fault, and yet I am not to blame. In that lies all the tragedy of it," he said to himself.

Clearly not his problem -- he was tempted, end of story.  His own fault yet he was not to blame.

Tolstoy wrote the sister-in-law, Dolly, as a saintly but tormented soul.  An epitome.  An ideal madonna.  Anna, frightened by this woman's determination to let her own virtue overcome (cough*patriarchal*cough) duty to her husband, manipulates her by suggesting first that she's not there to condone Stiva or to make excuses for him.  Instead, after letting her vent a bit, Anna turns the tables on Dolly's virtue, saying only she could have enough love to forgive him.

A few pages later Anna, herself married, falls in with a wealthy, noble cavalry officer. And despite urging it on Dolly she herself, lacking the ability to maternally submerge herself in her husband's welfare, generally makes everyone's lives miserable before jumping under a train.

Aah, but the dancing in that movie, choreographed to perfection with the music, was supernal.


Tags:

Wow that is great dancing,

Submitted by Jake Klarity (not verified) on Mon, 2013-01-28 06:22.

Wow that is great dancing, thanks for spotting it.   So often the dancing in movies these days is awful.  I guess I'll have to slog through the awful plot to watch the movie for the dancing....

It was an enormous

Submitted by Irene (not verified) on Mon, 2013-01-28 14:55.

It was an enormous disappointment to me to find out that Tolstoy had such a horrible side to him. I suppose it was like being the son of a plantation owner -- of course you have a right to the serf women.

I'd want some more

Submitted by Anonymous2 (not verified) on Tue, 2013-01-29 15:39.

I'd want some more information before deciding about Tolstoy's attitudes towards women.  It seems that what he did with Anna Karenin is very similar to and likely heavily influenced by Flaubert's Emma Bovary (though Tolstoy's detail is more influenced by his paid-by-the-word rate than a commitment to realism).  There are even similarities between the ball scenes.  Thomas Hardy, Kate Chopin--they also wrote about "fallen women" but were condemnatory of the society that limited women's life choices, even choices in love.

I'd forgotten about the release of Anna Karenin.  This sounds better to see than Les Miserables, though I don't know about Keira Knightly for this role.  (I've loved her in other roles, just not sure about the casting in this one.)

The hands are quite expressive--maybe the choreographer wanted to allude to Russian ballet.

I won't say that Madame

Submitted by Irene (not verified) on Tue, 2013-01-29 17:02.

I won't say that Madame Bovary and so on weren't models, but the main inspiration was probably closer to home -- Tolstoy's sister Marya had an affair (including having a daughter by her lover) after separating from her husband.

Thanks for this

Submitted by Anonymous2 (not verified) on Wed, 2013-01-30 11:21.

Thanks for this information--that's something I didn't know about.  I wonder what his attitude toward his sister was--judgment or shame, maybe then, versus condemnation of social mores that led to unwise marriages and prevented divorce.

They were pretty close, and I

Submitted by Irene (not verified) on Wed, 2013-01-30 13:40.

They were pretty close, and I get the impression he was sympathetic to her. But I'm far from an expert on the Tolstoys.

User login