domestic roles

Sharing Domestic Tasks Has to Mean *Sharing* Them. Exchanging "Housewives" for "Houseboys" Won't Cut It.

Gwen of Sociological Images, discussing a reality show called “Househusbands of Hollywood,” quotes one of the participant bios (ellipses hers, emphasis mine)

The pair… made a deal as newlyweds that she would bring home the paycheck so he could focus on his acting career… Katherine emails Danny a daily to-do list...

Read the quote in context here.

One of the deeper problems with gender roles, related the “super-mom” overtasking of the 1970s and 1980s, is that even when men, especially stay-at-home men, take on more of the “homemaker” roles women still consider household tasks their responsibility.

In my first, second and third-hand experience this shows up in the following ways

  • Other women frequently “complement” or congratulate the working female partner for having a “helpful” partner; other women frequently complement the man for helping his partner. And meanwhile…
  • The men in question rarely take ownership of their roles or push back.
  • Working women tend to remain the “task master,” setting standards, determining priorities, and even, as in the quote above, “emailing daily to-do lists” to the stay-at-home man. And meanwhile…
  • The men in question rarely take ownership of their roles or push back.
  • When men take over primary domestic tasks working women often fill in the freed-up time they… probably wouldn’t do if they were themselves performing the primary tasks, and meanwhile…
  • The men in question rarely take ownership of their roles or push back.

And on. The point being that the idea of men being responsible for housework is still so tenuous that even when men do take it on (how well or how poorly) it’s still almost universally assumed to be women’s work in the sense that women are merely seen — by themselves, by other women, and even by their partners — as, at best, delegating housework to their partners instead of sharing or dropping it.

And yes I’m aware of all manner of arguments for why this should be, from still-internalised traditions of women’s worth being assessed entirely on their domestic prowess, to women’s “higher” standards and/or men’s “lower” ones, to women being more delicate and prone to “infections” and men being coarser and “killing giraffes,” to men still not thinking in terms of taking ownership of their roles and instead deferring to pan-gender peer pressure, to the domestic sphere traditionally being the only place women were permitted autonomy, expertise, and authority.

But whatever the reason if we’re going to get closer to a genuinely egalitarian society we’ve got to cut it out. And the thing is (as I may have over-hinted) this is one of those things where it’s not going to be enough for women to give it up. In this case men have to pick it up. Or nobody’s going to be happy: the current alternative where women give up being housewives in favor of men becoming houseboys isn’t orthogonal.

One suspects this will never come up in Fox’s new program.

Update: Sarah Haskins brilliantly illustrates the social gradient.

Sure, like we’re going to let you going to leave him in charge of the house so you can… um… have a complete, not-my-problem career as primary breadwinner!

Incremental Progress But Still Progress: "Almost One-Third of Men Are Now Principal Shoppers in the Household"

Sadie of Jezebel says

n the last 20 years, household roles have shifted: whereas the supermarket used to be the woman’s domain, today “almost one-third of men are now the principal shoppers in the household.”

Read Sadie’s quote in context here.

This isn’t exactly breaking news to the principal shoppers in households. This is good news though.

The sooner we can get to really, serious equal divisions of labor the sooner we’ll get away from that egregious “there’s nothing sexier than a man doing [some item of housework].” And towards, oh, say, “there’s nothing sexier than having lots of spare time for each other because all domestic tasks done in half the time because we split the work.”

If you’re an adult you can click here to see a not-very-work-safe housekeeping image.

Ass-u-me: Make A Beast of Burden Out of U and Me

Photo by Flickr user Onnufry used under a Creative Commons license.

This post is about gender assumptions. In this case both “assume” in the normal sense of “impose by expectation informed by stereotype” but also “assume” in the sense of “take on titles, offices, duties, responsibilities.”

Emily Bazelon of Slate’s quasi-ghettoized XX-Factor blog raises two good points, one about stereotyping forward, the other about struggling out of self-stereotype.

This morning one of my co-workers was worrying about a conversation he’d had with a mother at his daughter’s school, who’d tried to talk to him about rearranging a playdate for his kid and hers. He hadn’t known anything about the arrangement in the first place, and I said that most moms would know not to try to talk playdate with a dad. Which didn’t exactly give him credit for trying to sort it all out, or encourage him to try again next time. This is why when my husband chides me for referring to “my kitchen,” I say I’m sorry. At least I think I do.

She said it here.

Play dates are easy for women because play dates are easy for the stay at home parent and, still, more often than not, women are the stay at home parent.

As the stay at home dad I’m nominally supposed to do most of the play date arranging. And indeed since I pick up our children from school more often than my partner since she’s often working I do arrange more play dates over all — mostly by being grabbed by this child or that asking “can we have a play date?” If the mom (there are still usually only a few other dads at school) is at hand we negotiate it there. Otherwise it’s out with my cell phone and (since the youngest is in 3rd grade now and, of course, the play date candidates know their parent’s phone number) I let them ask permission of which ever parent they see fit. Sometimes we arrange play dates in advance but those are usually ordered around things like soccer practice or games where I just bring home children to play till practice. Parents usually pick up their own children and often one of them will return mine so I don’t have to make an extra trip. Sometimes you or another child’s parent makes calls and arrange play dates in advance.

That all works fabulously well and it’s extraordinarily easy to keep track of.

If you’re the one making the arrangements.

That all works fabulously well, too, and is extraordinarily easy for one’s partner to keep track of if…

if…

if and only if…
You write it down where the other partner(s) can see it should they need to know! In other words it’s not a testicle thing. It’s not an ovary thing. It’s a calendar/schedule/daytimer/communication thing.

Also a is-this-a-shared-responsibility thing, of course, and that makes a nice segue into Bazelon’s second point: who’s kitchen is it?

I do virtually all the shopping and cooking in our house, from first coffee in the morning to breakfast (something hot and home-made most days like oatmeal, steamed pot-stickers, pancakes or eggs, with cold cereal once or twice) to school lunches (sometimes a sandwich, sometimes freshly steamed veggies with nori seaweed, sometimes left-over soup or fresh-cooked spaghetti or ravioli) to dinner (I won’t even start) to desserts if there are any to late night snacks (if, for instance, ramen or some other kind of soup is requested.) And while I certainly don’t do all the cleanup I do quite a bit.

That’s been the arrangement for roughly as long as our 5th grader has been in school. Every now and then, though, my partner still gets nettled about the way I prioritize kitchen cleanup. Indoctrination runs deep. The funny thing is that any time she goes off that way I initially cringe and start apologizing for… what? Messing up her kitchen? Yes, it’s silly. And yes even though I spend a lot of time there it’s still our kitchen. But we each had that Kool-aid poured for us long before we could speak.

But “poured for us” isn’t the same as “bred into us.” Our children may have their own domestic manias and obsessions when they grow up, but I’ll be surprised if they’re the same as ours.

Photo by Flickr user onnufry used under a Creative Commons license.

Syndicate content