figleaf finds the perfect romantic musical

| Tags:
Sun, 2007-07-29 21:57

I gotta say I just loved, loved, loved Jim Carney’s Once. Loved it. Cried through half of it, felt like a doofus for it, didn’t give a shit.

It’s just a perfect reconceptualization of the whole idea of what a movie musical ought to be — just barely enough plot to hold the songs together… except that instead of bursting into song for no good reason at all, stopping everything, and hoofing it around in antic costumery… the characters are working and/or aspiring musicians who just show each other what music they’re working with in their respective lives.

And what’s just so cool is that while they’re attracted to each other, and on top of that they mean something to each other, other parts of their respective lives have their own pull and so more than everything else they have the music the put together first over lunch breaks in music store pianos, or late night drinking and singing sessions with friends (my partner says this is more common in Ireland, where the movies’ set, than in the states), and then finally in an all-night recording studio session with other Dublin street musicians recruited for the occasion. And then…

Not to change the subject (or give anything away) but the actors playing the lead man and woman (their characters are never named) wrote and performed nearly all the songs.

Sigh.

Something else that’s so cool is that while they lyrics of the songs don’t carry the plot — they’re just songs two very, very good aspiring musicians might write — the way they’re played, filmed, acted in character carry the show.

Sigh.

I just loved that movie. If more musicals were like that I’d really like musicals a lot more. See it if you get the chance.

Submitted by 1517 (not verified) on Mon, 2007-07-30 15:23.

I found and watched the trailer last night. Cried all through it, glad to know it's not just PMS. Is this out on DVD?

[I don't think it's on DVD yet. Glad someone else was touched like that. It's sort of what music videos ought to do but largely don't, and for that matter what opera ought to do but often doesn't -- the songs themselves are perfectly swell but in the context of the film they're wonderful and in the context of an ongoing narrative where the acting inside singing the song is pushed forward... just a lovely effect! Thanks, Cathy. --fl]

Submitted by 1517 (not verified) on Mon, 2007-07-30 07:46.

Good Monday morning to you, Figleaf !

I'll go see it. Thanks for the recommendation.

I love musicals and haven't seen one I thought was faulous since Phantom of the Opera... I'm an old Rogers & Hammerstein bufff, too...

Looking forward to it.

Sincerely,
Loving Annie

p.s. Do you like what I write ??? Not here, (but yeah, that too.) I mean on my erotica blog.
You don't ever comment, but I see your site on the stat counter...

You are always welcome to visit, and I'd love your feedback if you were so inclined !

Thanks,
Sincerely,
Loving Annie

[While I don't ordinarily mind musicals, and I actually enjoy musical theater, I've tended to veer off. The reviews of this one promised something different and the movie lived up to it. As for erotica-only sites, I kind of ebb and flow on reading them, Annie, and these days the tide seems to be out. I'm sure I'll pull out of it or... I dunno... maybe slide back in sooner or later. Thanks. --fl]

Submitted by 1517 (not verified) on Sun, 2007-07-29 22:56.

I loved this movie. I have seen it twice and got the soundtrack as well.

I felt as though I was watching a video diary, almost like reading someone's journal, and seeing such simple yet everyday intimate things. It is a hard movie to explain to people yet I keep telling then to go.

Cinematic beauty.

[Yeah, the cinematography is just awesome. A lot of it seems to be done with hand-held cameras (though throughout there are these awesome continuous shots, panning shots, and so on) but the lighting and colors are incredibly rich. Yeah, cool movie. Thank you, J. --fl]

User login