Zula of A Submissive With Claws says (emphasis mine.)
According to the BBC, a new study shows that women physically suffer disproportionately in strained (heterosexual) marriages. Whereas men and women both showed signs of depression in unhappy marriages, only women showed elevated levels of hypertension, heart disease, etc.
According to some random counselor quoted in the article, “The gender difference could be partly due to the fact that women’s hormonal profile is more complex than men’s. Women also tend to worry more about their health than men.”
Oh, of course! We women are just walking bags of hormones and neuroses! It couldn’t possibly be because gender roles in marriage are far from equal and women get the short end of the stick more often than not. headdesk headdesk headdesk
I nicked the whole post from here because… what could you cut?.
Yeah, gee, hypertension huh? That doesn’t come from, oh, say, perpetually suppressing your autonomy, intelligence, agency, and sexuality, as some people — like educated professional writer and lecturer Martha Peace — say to this day
It’s common for a young Christian wife to rebel against home life as her primary ministry, Peace writes in Becoming a Titus 2 Woman, which lays out the principles of her ministry model. It’s the role of older women to help her understand her priorities.
Those priorities may include rising early to feed the family, being available anytime to satisfy a husband’s desires (barring a few “ungodly” or “homosexual” acts), seeking his approval regarding work, appearance, and leisure, and accepting that he has the “burden” of final say in arguments. After a wife has respectfully appealed her spouse’s decisionâ€â€a privilege she should not abuseâ€â€she must accept his final answer as “God’s will for her at that time,” Peace advises. The godly wife must also suppress selfish desires (for romance, a career, an equitable marriage), practice addressing her spouse in soothing tones, and maintain a private log of bitter thoughts to guide her repentance. “If you disobey your husband,” Peace admonishes in The Excellent Wife, “you are indirectly shaking your fist at God.”
Nope, must be them hormones. (And not your husband, lord, master, and undivorcable conduit to Christ saying, for the 1000th time despite your “respectful appeal” because he thought it was funny the previous 999, “hormones huh? Yuknow how to make a whore moan…?”)
Oh, and, y’know, every day I wake up thinking my lucky stars that men are steady, stable, and completely uninfluenced by our hormones, which, if we had any, would be uncomplicated and never unexpectedly spike in ways that compel us to, oh, say, make impulse decisions we later regret.




Submitted by 2777 (not verified) on Sun, 2009-03-15 10:56.
Actually, while I think the quotation from the article is pretty boneheaded (isn't it more likely that men *don't worry enough* about their health?) the hormonal question is more complex.
I assume you and Zula probably read "hormones" as meaning "sex hormones" (estrogen, etc.), but there is some evidence implicating *stress* hormones such as cortisol in metabolic syndrome. Women tend to have chronically elevated levels of cortisol, compared to men, quite possibly (though not definitely) due to social factors such as the double burden of work or other inequalities in marriage. Cortisol seems to rise when people feel a lack of control, too. So it's not implausible that marital problems - added to other social stressors - would push women's stress hormones to damagingly high levels.
I'm not an expert on this stuff but I think it's important not to automatically assume hormones = sex hormones.
[Hi Sungold! Of course you're right that they, and so by extension Zula and I, were referring to sex hormones. And yes, cortisol and the other stress hormones (adrenaline, etc.) moderated (or not!) by the sympathetic nervous system have a much bigger impact on all of us. Insulin being another hormone that, of course, affects all of us significantly. But I took their phrase "women's hormonal profile is more complex than men's" as code for sex hormones. I appreciate you making the case expressly that whereas you could imagine "blaming" women for having weeks-long hormone cycles (as opposed to men's, um, daily testosterone cycles) the hormones responsible for the heart disease and hypertension mentioned in the article have very little to do with gendered endocrinology. And almost everything to do with gender *roles.* Thanks! --fl]